Fat, Not Meat, Might Have Fueled the Growth of Hominin Brains
Written on
Chapter 1: A New Perspective on Hominin Diet
Recent research challenges long-standing beliefs about how our ancestors enhanced their brainpower. A significant theory posits that fat, rather than meat, may have played a crucial role in the evolution of larger brains among early hominins.
In a groundbreaking review published in February's Current Anthropology, anthropologist Jessica Thompson and her team argue that the consumption of fatty nutrients from marrow and brain may have preceded the use of sharpened tools for hunting meat. This re-evaluation pushes back the timeline for tool use and dietary changes by approximately 800,000 years.
Section 1.1: Evidence from Ancient Ethiopia
Northern Ethiopia was once the site of a massive ancient lake, where saber-toothed cats and gigantic crocodiles thrived. The sediments left behind over 3 million years ago provide a rich fossil record, including early hominin remains discovered by Thompson in 2010.
Section 1.2: Reevaluating the Role of Meat in Human Evolution
Traditionally, it was believed that the development of flaked tools and the consumption of meat were pivotal for the emergence of modern humans over 2 million years ago. However, Thompson's findings suggest that earlier hominins may have prioritized accessing nutrient-rich marrow and brain matter from bones, rather than hunting large animals.
Chapter 2: A Shift in Understanding
The first video, titled "TIME: Sorry Vegans, Meat Made Us Human Response," explores how the narrative surrounding meat consumption has shaped human evolution.
The second video, "Their Own Results Were 'A Big Surprise' - Meat Made Us Human Study," discusses unexpected findings related to the meat consumption theory in human evolution.
The emergence of the "human predatory pattern" has been linked with the notion of hunting larger prey, which historically has been viewed as integral to human development. Yet, the latest research indicates that early hominins may have initially focused on scavenging rather than active hunting.
In the past few decades, the theory that hominins scavenged large animal carcasses for nutrient-dense marrow has gained traction. The recent review posits that marrow could have been a more accessible and safer nutritional source compared to raw meat, which presents considerable risks and challenges.
The study emphasizes that as environmental conditions shifted during the Pliocene, early hominins began to exploit new dietary opportunities. By around 3.5 million years ago, species such as Australopithecus displayed increased brain size and anatomical adaptations that suggest a greater reliance on tool use.
While some experts remain skeptical about the implications of this research, the review opens avenues for further exploration. Researchers are encouraged to search for evidence of percussive tools that predate flaked implements, potentially reshaping our understanding of early hominin behavior.
Richard Kemeny, a freelance science journalist based in São Paulo, Brazil, highlights the significance of these findings in understanding our evolutionary history.