Innovative Approach to Integrate Protein Structures in Cryo-EM Maps
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to Cryo-Electron Microscopy
The recent preprint introduces a groundbreaking tool that has the potential to transform how cryo-electron microscopy (CryoEM) and machine learning are utilized in predicting protein structures. Structural biology is currently at the forefront of research across biology, biotechnology, and medicine, primarily due to its ability to elucidate biological phenomena through the lens of chemistry and physics. The integration of computer science has significantly accelerated advancements in this field.
Traditional methods for determining atomic-level protein structures, such as nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and X-ray crystallography, often struggle with larger, more flexible proteins. CryoEM has emerged as a powerful technique capable of tackling these larger protein systems and complexes. However, it also encounters limitations that the new methodology aims to address.
CryoEM determines the structure of protein molecules by directing electrons at flash-frozen samples and capturing the resulting images to create 3D maps, into which atomic structures can be modeled. The acquisition of these 3D maps necessitates processing extensive datasets, resulting in complex electron density representations over three-dimensional grids. To accurately model atoms within these maps, researchers must ensure compatibility with both the data and established principles of chemistry and molecular geometry. While this task is manageable at high resolutions, it becomes increasingly challenging as resolution decreases.
In recent years, CryoEM has gained traction in structural biology as it achieves higher resolutions, challenging the dominance of traditional X-ray crystallography and NMR. Each method possesses its unique strengths and weaknesses; however, CryoEM currently holds a prominent position among the three techniques.
Despite the increasing capabilities of CryoEM, the majority of maps produced today are of mid to low resolution, complicating the modeling of individual atoms for protein structure reconstruction. Nevertheless, if partial protein structures are known or can be modeled through innovative methods like AlphaFold, researchers can fit these structures into CryoEM 3D maps, yielding detailed models even from low-resolution data.
The first video, titled "Machine learning for determining protein structure and dynamics from cryo-EM images," explores how machine learning techniques can enhance the determination of protein structures from CryoEM data.
Chapter 2: Addressing Fitting Challenges with MaD
The process of fitting protein structures into CryoEM maps in three-dimensional space poses significant challenges. A recent preprint from our lab introduces a novel methodology inspired by computer vision techniques, particularly the challenge of locating known shapes within images. This new tool, named Macromolecular Descriptors (MaD), aims to streamline and semi-automate the fitting process for scientists working with CryoEM maps.
Currently, researchers manually fit structures into maps, relying on local optimization tools for final adjustments. With MaD, a greater portion of this work can be automated, expediting the process and reducing subjectivity and potential errors. MaD takes the 3D map obtained from a CryoEM experiment and one or more target structures, computing and scoring various fits to deliver probable models for further refinement.
The second video titled "Machine learning for reconstructing dynamic protein structures from cryo-EM images" illustrates how machine learning aids in reconstructing protein structures from CryoEM data.
Section 2.1: How MaD Operates
MaD employs a feature-based approach influenced by local feature descriptors found in computer vision. In this domain, descriptors are utilized for image registration, reconstruction, and object detection. Typically, these descriptors are constructed from local regions surrounding feature points, designed for rotational invariance and robustness against noise.
MaD incorporates a modified form of scale-invariant feature transform (SIFT) descriptors. Initially, MaD projects input structures onto a grid that matches the spacing of the input CryoEM data. The resulting grid is convolved with a Gaussian kernel, and anchors are collected from voxels with intensity exceeding that of their neighbors. This process is similarly applied to the CryoEM map.
Once the anchors are refined, they are ready for fitting. MaD extracts spherical patches around each anchor and builds histograms from the gradient vectors within these patches. A rotation matrix is derived from the histogram’s highest vector counts, guiding the translations and rotations needed to fit each protein component into the map. As more structures are incorporated, solutions are refined based on density gradients while ensuring any clashes are resolved.
Section 2.2: Applications of MaD
MaD’s approach effectively matches descriptors to produce solutions where protein structures fit within electron density maps, demonstrating efficiency and accuracy even at low and medium resolutions. As highlighted in the preprint, MaD has the potential to provide essential structural details, especially in the context of low-quality maps. The tool is expected to work seamlessly with machine learning-derived protein structures, such as those generated by AlphaFold, to validate and improve structural models by fitting them into mid-resolution CryoEM maps.
Furthermore, MaD is also applicable to high-resolution data. While it might seem unnecessary to fit atoms into high-resolution maps using standard structure-solving programs, MaD can expedite structure determination through automation. The preprint presents an instance where a multitude of conformations from molecular dynamics simulations are fitted into a target map, scored, and the most probable structures proposed.
Section 2.3: Case Study - The GroEL Protein
An advanced case study presented in the preprint focuses on the GroEL tetradecameric protein, a cage-like structure composed of 14 protein copies. This protein functions as a chaperone, assisting in the folding of other proteins.
In this example, the authors docked 14 GroEL copies from an X-ray structure into a CryoEM map exhibiting structural deviations. Due to these deviations, a perfect fit was unattainable if the protein was treated as a static structure. To address this, the researchers conducted a molecular dynamics simulation, allowing the GroEL structure to explore conformational variations. Utilizing their tool, CLoNe, they identified seven relevant cluster centers and docked 14 copies of each into CryoEM maps representing both open and closed forms of the tetradecameric protein. MaD successfully retrieved confident models of the tetradecameric structure resolved at atomic levels for both states.
The ability of MaD to reconstruct large assemblies within CryoEM maps is significant. Traditional techniques for determining atomic-level protein structures often capture discrete snapshots of structures, but MaD streamlines molecular reconstructions, effectively incorporating lower resolution data, both new and existing.
The structural biology community requires innovative tools like MaD to integrate flexibility into structure generation workflows and utilize sub-optimal resolution data. By facilitating these advancements, MaD could represent a major breakthrough in structural biology research, bridging the gap between computer vision and molecular biology.