Challenges in Combating Illicit Finance

Melican, drawing from his extensive experience in compliance, emphasized the difficulties associated with identifying and mitigating fraudulent transactions. He noted that clients often ask, “Can you scale? Can you incorporate new asset classes?” The rapid evolution of the cryptocurrency landscape makes it increasingly challenging for firms to adapt to both industry changes and fluctuating government regulations.

The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has also shed light on another pressing issue: the potential misuse of cryptocurrency. The global support for Ukraine has manifested in significant bitcoin donations, while there are concerns over possible Russian attempts to evade sanctions through cryptocurrency. This duality presents a complex dilemma for firms trying to ascertain whether funds exiting their platforms are being used for legitimate purposes.

Melican remarked, “Crypto is the worst way in the world to launder money,” addressing the Federal Reserve's scrutiny of illicit bitcoin activities.

Consumer Protection and Regulatory Oversight

Howard voiced concerns regarding consumer protection, particularly pointing to the current stance of SEC Chairman Gary Gensler. He described Gensler as having a “very expansive view on regulation,” adding that the SEC’s approach to stablecoins mirrors that of money market accounts, which he finds problematic.

Lennon highlighted that state-level regulations can sometimes be more burdensome than federal ones, citing New York's “BitLicense” as a barrier to innovation. She noted that Washington seems to be directing its focus more on altcoins due to the prevalence of fraud in that area, while Bitcoin receives comparatively less attention.

The Gaps in U.S. Bitcoin Regulation

Douyer echoed the sentiment shared by the panelists regarding significant regulatory voids in the U.S. He emphasized two primary issues: the lack of consensus among major regulatory bodies like the SEC and the U.S. Department of the Treasury regarding their respective jurisdictions and the fragmented relationship between federal and state regulators, a point that Lennon also raised.

Howard elaborated on how these regulatory uncertainties are causing major institutions to remain cautious. As cryptocurrency evolves, it is becoming increasingly institutionalized, yet it struggles to scale without clear guidance from regulatory authorities.

He expressed frustration over the SEC’s continued delay in approving a bitcoin spot exchange-traded fund (ETF), while innovations are moving forward in other countries, particularly in Germany. Lennon mentioned that some clients even inquire about how to avoid U.S. regulations, indicating a lack of optimism.

Hope for Future Regulations

Is there a glimmer of hope for the regulatory landscape in the U.S.? Melican suggested that President Biden’s recent executive order signifies a positive step towards establishing sensible regulations in the cryptocurrency arena. This order calls for federal agencies to coordinate their efforts and work towards a cohesive regulatory framework for digital assets. Other panelists shared this view, although they acknowledged that the implementation of these efforts will take time.

In closing, Byrne remarked, “As far as advising clients on Bitcoin and crypto regulations, I’m very comfortable with my future job security.”

Subscribe on Substack — Always Free!