# The Evolution of Luxury: From Quiet Luxury to Personal Style
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Quiet Luxury
Luxury fashion items often serve as strong indicators of social status. Owning an exclusive Patek Philippe watch or being able to recognize and purchase the latest must-have item speaks volumes. However, different fashion choices send varied messages. While flashy logos are losing their appeal, quiet luxury represents a level of success so profound that it no longer requires overt signaling.
In the HBO series Succession, a character is criticized for carrying a conspicuous Burberry handbag at a high-society gathering, implying that subtlety is key in elite circles.
This quotation highlights the tension between overt displays of wealth and the understated elegance that is now favored:
"What's even in there?…Flat shoes for the subway? Her lunch pail? It's gargantuan. You could take it camping." — Tom Wambsgans, Succession
Paul Graham’s essay, "Cities and Ambition," further illustrates how status markers vary by location. For instance, in Boston, intelligence is prioritized, while Silicon Valley emphasizes power. New York, on the other hand, values financial wealth, even if it is inherited.
Luxury brands offer a spectrum of status messages, ranging from financial success to more nuanced symbols of social approval and taste.
Section 1.1: The Rise of Fakes in Luxury
The fashion status hierarchy appears straightforward until you consider the trend of ultra-wealthy individuals opting for counterfeit luxury items. What message does this send?
A friend of mine, whom I'll call Nicole, is quite affluent—owning multiple beachfront properties and frequently flying private. Yet, she chooses to buy counterfeit handbags and often offers to get me one as well.
"Send me a photo of a bag—my guy will get you the exact one." — Nicole
An article from The Cut titled "The Rich New York Women who Love Their Fake Birkins" discusses the networks that facilitate the trade of these counterfeit items, likening them to modern Tupperware parties. This trend suggests that possessing a high-quality fake has become a new form of status, sometimes eclipsing the value of the genuine article.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Appeal of Counterfeits
Nicole exemplifies how having access to quality replicas can signify a certain social savvy. Purchasing a high-end item is straightforward for those with financial means, but discovering a quality counterfeit demonstrates wit and connections.
"If you have money, anyone can buy the most expensive trendy item. But finding something that isn’t mainstream yet still exudes quality requires effort and taste." — Friend of author
This phenomenon hints at a deeper issue: the illusion of luxury is beginning to unravel. The craftsmanship behind brands like Hermès, which can take up to 40 hours to produce a single item, raises questions about the brand's prestige when a counterfeit can replicate the experience.
Section 1.2: Discontent with Luxury Pricing
Recently, the Wall Street Journal featured an article about luxury consumers growing weary of rising prices. One shopper, Heiji Choy Black, expressed her disappointment after realizing that basic luxury items, like denim, often exceed $1,000.
"The bud was off the rose," she remarked.
This sentiment resonates with others, including friends who have access to luxury goods:
"These bags are so overpriced. The Chanel 2.55 classic was $1,200 back in 2006, and now it’s over $10K. They can do it because they can." — Friend of author
In the past, luxury prices were a badge of honor, signaling exclusivity. Today, many consumers feel exploited by exorbitant pricing. Quiet luxury allows individuals to abstain from flaunting their ability to pay high prices, while counterfeit items provide an alternative that challenges the status quo.
Chapter 2: The Future of Luxury
The first video, The Subtle Difference Between Old Money And Quiet Luxury, explores the nuances of wealth and how they reflect personal values in fashion.
The second video, 10 LUXURY BRANDS THAT MAKE YOU LOOK CHEAP - quiet luxury trend, delves into the perception of luxury brands and their evolution in today’s market.
As the landscape of luxury evolves, the definition of status is also changing. If traditional luxury is perceived as less prestigious—who wants to admit to being overcharged by Chanel?—what will replace it? Perhaps the answer lies in creativity, personal style, and authenticity.
The Business of Fashion’s Brand Magic Index reveals that most luxury brands embody serious archetypes, like the Ruler or Hero. However, the rise of counterfeit culture indicates a shift in consumer desire; we are increasingly drawn to rebellion and individuality.
Ultimately, whether or not one splurges on a Goyard handbag, they are still engaging with the luxury narrative, albeit through a different lens.
The emerging trend points towards a movement away from both ostentatious and subdued luxury toward a celebration of personal identity. Rather than relying on logos to signify wealth, the highest status may now lie in showcasing one’s unique style.
"Anyone can walk into Polo Bar wearing all-designer everything — all it takes is money," noted a private equity partner. Instead, she opts for items that reflect her individuality from a boutique that offers more distinct choices.
New status signals are redefining the luxury market. If creativity and personal style are now the benchmarks of status, where does that leave traditional luxury brands? They must adapt to meet the evolving desires of consumers, finding innovative ways to embody self-expression and creativity.
In conclusion, the nature of status is fluid, shaped by societal trends and perceptions. Luxury brands must remain vigilant and responsive to these changes, emphasizing self-confidence as a timeless aspiration. Perhaps it’s time for brands to design with this principle in mind.
✨ Follow or subscribe for access to all pieces on brand strategy and marketing ✨ Looking to make your luxury brand more relevant? I run a consultancy called Embedded, where I collaborate with companies on growth and brand strategy. Not sure where to begin? Many clients choose ad-hoc coaching—hourly consultations on any aspect of your marketing and brand strategy. Get in touch here, or book a 15-minute free consultation.