Exploring Gym Options: $20 vs. $300 Memberships in NYC
Written on
Chapter 1: The Gym Landscape in NYC
Navigating the gym scene in New York City can be quite a challenge. Having explored two neighborhoods—East Harlem and the Lower East Side—I discovered three predominant types of gyms:
- The low-budget gym at $20, featuring mediocre equipment and a less-than-ideal atmosphere.
- A mixed martial arts “gym” priced at $50, lacking sufficient heavy weights.
- A high-end gym costing $250, boasting shiny, chrome-plated plates, elegant wooden floors, and amenities like massages and saunas.
These are pretty much the only gym options available in NYC. Coming from Oklahoma City, where a premium gym membership costs only $10, I was both surprised and bewildered.
So, I decided to try all three gym types to see how they measure up.
This paragraph will result in an indented block of text, typically used for quoting other text.
Section 1.1: The Equinox Experience
“Equinox members shouldn’t have to deal with basic issues like gravity.” — Dom Mazzetti
If I’m shelling out $300 a month for a gym, I expect them to treat my body with the utmost care—like a valet service. According to its reputation, that’s the essence of the Equinox experience.
Equinox operates more like a social club than a traditional gym. It’s akin to the Ritz Carlton of fitness centers. The equipment is top-notch, and the range of classes, including yoga, Pilates, and spinning, is extensive.
But is the expense justified? Here’s a breakdown of what Equinox provides:
- Minimal Crowds: The steep fees tend to deter larger crowds, allowing for a more serene workout experience (unless financial stress is a concern).
- Pristine Facilities: I turned my Upper East Side Equinox into a second home, utilizing its clean showers and convenient restrooms, which are a rarity in NYC.
- Steam Room Access: While it may sound trivial, steam rooms and saunas have health benefits, including the stimulation of heat shock proteins and a slight release of human growth hormone (HGH).
- Engaging Atmosphere: Especially in NYC, mingling with affluent individuals became a regular occurrence, although it didn’t lead to dating opportunities.
The true value of Equinox hinges on your frequency of visits. Attending five times a week reduces the cost to $15 per session. If you enjoy the luxurious amenities, it becomes even more worthwhile. Personally, I believe Equinox is worth it only for individuals living in major cities who are deeply committed to fitness—more so than to their own families.
Section 1.2: Planet Fitness—An Underappreciated Option
I don’t understand the negative perceptions surrounding Planet Fitness. The reality is that most people aren’t elite bodybuilders.
After five months of dedicated training there, I can confidently say I’m in the best shape of my life. At just $10 a month and only two minutes from my home, it’s a fantastic deal.
Here’s what you can expect from Planet Fitness:
- Basic Equipment: The facility provides all the necessary equipment, although it lacks barbells. Surprisingly, the rate of broken equipment is similar to what I experienced at Equinox.
- Smith Machine: This is essentially a restrictive device for weight lifting that can hinder effective squats and deadlifts, so it’s best to avoid it for compound movements.
- Welcoming Community: Contrary to popular belief, I’ve found both serious lifters and beginners at Planet Fitness. It’s often criticized for being too social, but my experiences have been quite the opposite.
- Busy Peak Hours: The downside to affordability is that the gym can be overcrowded during peak times, making it challenging to work out.
If you’re a serious lifter, perhaps Planet Fitness isn’t your best fit. However, for the vast majority of people, it’s more than adequate.
Chapter 2: Evaluating CrossFit
I happened to walk by a CrossFit gym and noticed that nearly everyone inside appeared larger than I am, despite my own five years of lifting experience at 175 pounds.
That said, CrossFit has its merits, particularly in developing a well-rounded fitness profile. One doesn’t truly appreciate the impact of cardiovascular health on lifting performance until they experience improved conditioning.
Personally, I’m not drawn to the group fitness vibe. While I occasionally join a running club or partner with a friend for a workout, I generally prefer to train solo. However, if your goals include improving calisthenics or you thrive in a group setting, I wholeheartedly recommend CrossFit. My local CrossFit gym charges around $99 monthly, making it relatively affordable.
Final Thoughts
In examining the fitness industry in NYC and other major cities, it’s clear that traditional gyms are being supplanted by specialized “experience” gyms—think hot yoga, cycling studios, boxing, and CrossFit.
While I find myself at Planet Fitness due to its affordability, if finances were not a concern, I would switch to Equinox in a heartbeat. Nonetheless, I believe Planet Fitness is excellent for what it offers.
Ultimately, your choice of gym depends on your fitness priorities. Understanding your own needs is crucial to finding the right fit. Best of luck!
Join over 4,000 subscribers on my Substack for a copy of my new eBook “Gold2.0.”
The first video, $20 A Month Gym VS $300+ A Month Gym, discusses the differences between budget-friendly and luxury gym memberships, shedding light on what you can expect from each.
The second video, Why Spend $500 a Month On Gym Memberships When…, explores whether high-cost memberships are truly worth the investment, offering insights and alternatives for fitness enthusiasts.